Games as a Matter of Life and Death; or, The Pitiful State of Would-be Gods
What matters the game? Why do I rage and hoot upon seeing some arrangement of dots on cubes of plastic?
why do I bury my face in my hands as my opponent poorly narrates the killing blow of some deaf and dumb man
against another deaf and dumb man? Why do I feel like some king toppled from his throne, which felt so secure only moments past?
I do not wish to generalise my feelings, only to intuit something with reference to certain ideas, theories or
notions that I assume, consciously or otherwise, in figuring out why I feel the way I feel. I will begin with what
I consider the main consuming problem which I believe most if not all actions I take and feelings I experience are tied to,
that of course being death. While I have not read in full the works of Ernest Becker, I feel inclined to agree with his
principal points, namely (and I apologise if I summarise wrongly) that death, rather than fluff like sex or parental envy,
is the principal source and driver of the existential angst which all men must suffer. The fundamental
existential problem, that being a lack of meaning in life and the universe, can be seen as the fatal end point of man’s
search for an enduring life beyond his own finite and fleshy own; man fears his own death, his own fleshiness, his own
creaturliness, and seeks out an enduring life in that beyond himself, from friends and family, to his city, to his nation, to his ideology,
to his God. When we follow this path and find nothing at the end, that is the source of terror and angst which makes up our suffering.
But this is elementary stuff, what does this have to do with games? Surely games (specifically strategy games, in my case) are an escape from
all this depressing navel gazing, a chance to take ‘time off’ from the dreary business of life. Not so, I say! For I argue that games are merely an exercise
in ‘going over’ those facts which we most desire to leave behind, a kind of pharmakon that decieves us as a remedy or drug to our disease, but which ends up
poisoning us in some way or another. I will use the example of the miniature wargame in my analysis, but I believe any points made by me are applicable to other forms of
game as well, be they card games, dice games, video games, etc.
As per Ernest Becker (I think!), man wishes to achieve some kind of immortality, that is, an escape from the consciousness of his own fleshy, creaturely, mortal
existence, an existence which must necessarily terminate in death. Games, particularly strategy games such as miniature wargames, are an apparent candidate for this
kind of immortality, as they are games which principally challenge a person’s intellectual faculties. In order to win at these games you have to be a good strategist,
that is, excel at observation, planning, decision making and prediction. When a person excels at these things, he briefly escapes the creaturely life of instinct and
fear, instead taking his seat on the Throne of God, taking a perfect omniscient view of the battlefield as he executes the right series of moves to win the game,
thereby highlighting his capacity as a rational being, thereby (again, briefly) placing the victor in the mind of God, that is, a purely calm, collected, and rational being.
To play at strategy games is to play at being God.
But what of chance, you say? Anyone familiar with miniature wargames is aware of the role chance has in the game, namely through the use of rolling dice to determine the outcome
of an action (for example a fight between two figures). Not only that, but chance plays a significant part in the mechanics of the game, as virtually any major action or event in
the wargame is determined with the roll of the dice. Does this chancy element not dispel the illusion of Godhood? Not so! For while a meditation such as this may dispel the illusion
of immmortality after the fact (a point I will talk on later), in the midst of the game, the element of chance serves only to enhance the divine quality of play! The point I am making
is that wargames are games of life and death, brutal contests of bloodshed and slaughter which end with either absolute victory or absolute defeat (with the miserable prospect
of a draw lying somewhere in between). Such primal and essential qualities of the play align the player’s consciousness with the divine bloodshed of ancient times, with the war stories
of the Iliad, where the Gods themselves would descend from Olympus to fight alongside mortal men. There is something analogous in the wargame, namely in the act of rolling the dice: upon
reflection dice throwing is subject to chance, that miserable, materialist notion which strikes me as saying something was caused by nothing (for what the hell is chance anyway? A nothing,
a trifle, I say). But, in the throes of the game, the player can imagine the throw of the dice as the dice being fought over by benevolent and malevolent gods, between one’s Guardian spirit
and a jealous daemon, the former wishing to show six beautiful dots, the other wishing to land on a pitiful one. When the former utterly triumphs the dice show six, when the latter utterly
triumphs the dice show one, with the various degrees of victory corresponding to the numbers shown on the dice (4 and 5 being close victories for our guardian, 2 and 3 close victories for
the daemon). It is like that old Christian notion of an angel and devil fighting over a dead man’s soul as it leaves his body.
What does this amount to then? It means that in the midst of the game, a successful dice throw means that we are, in a sense distinct from the previous one mentioned, Godlike. Or, more
properly, Blessed or ‘Kissed’ by the Gods, for we feel (even if it is only subconsciously) that we have been touched by kind and benevolent Gods, spirits who wish to do right by us, who
wish to see us happy and blessed and content and joyful, and who are (by implication) strong in the face of our enemies, for a six or five only comes up in the event of our guardian spirits
triumphing over the rival daemons who support our opponent. What this means is that when we triumph in the game, when we achieve victory through effective strategy and effective dice
rolling, we are twice blessed, twice divine, twice immortal: for not only are we blessed by God through the roll of the dice, but we are like unto God in the cultivation of those faculties
closest to Him, namely our rational faculties. For just a moment, we become immortal, and the limited, fleshy, finite materialness of our Human selves, so prone to fear, doubts, angst,
so utterly disturbed by the looming threat of failure and death, is brushed away like dust by the radiant sun of victory.
But, the obvious question arises: what if you lose? This piece started with a rather brief and pathetic description of despair in the face of defeat, and I believe anyone paying attention
to what I have just written will come to understand the psychological resonance of defeat. If you do not understand, I will state it plainly: to lose is to be damned. If, try as we might,
we rack our brains to devise some cunning stratagem to overcome our opponent, only to realise at the last moment that we overlooked some crucial detail, committing a mistake which
ultimately spells doom for our beleaguered soldiers, then we are violently met with the brutal fact of our own limitations, our own creatureliness, our own mortality: for only a mortal
could make such a mistake. The force of this revelation thrusts us from the Throne of God, tramples underfoot our reason, our sole link to the divine, and leaves us only with what we have
in common with the animals, namely, fear, uncertainty, and idiotic instinct.
Equally, if we continue to throw the dice, again and again, and yet they continue to show the horrid face of one and two, we can infer a number of things: one, that our guardian spirits
either hate us or ignore us, leaving our poor dice to be molested by the grinning and lecherous daemon of our opponent; two, that our guardian spirit does care for us, but he is too weak,
powerless to take on the daemon of our opponent, and is overpowered time and time again in the battle of the dice. From this we can assume that, when we fail to win our dice rolls, either
the Gods hate us or care not a jot for us, or they do care for us, but they are powerless in the face of our enemies. Either way, we are most certainly not blessed or ‘kissed’ by the Gods,
but rather we are damned to be hated by them, or rather to be hated by those Gods who possess true power, that is the Gods of our victorious opponent. In short, we are not twice blessed,
twice immortal, twice Godlike, but twice damned, twice cursed, twice hated, twice dead, twice Human.
But why is this? If you have been reading this piece so far, you have probably arrived at some questions. These probably include ‘What the hell is he talking about?’, but they may also
include ‘Why does he think this? Why is he thinking about games in this way?’ My answer to this ultimately links back to my claim that games are a kind of pharmakon, that is, a drug or
substance which can be consumed but which may function either as remedy or poison. The truth (as I see it) is that games (among many other things) are one of many kinds of pharmakon, things
or activities that we seek after and engage with in order to alleviate our own sense of mortality and finiteness by securing ourselves a little piece of immortality. The means by which this
is achieved by miniature wargames I have already outlined above. The problem here is obviously the vicious binary of victory versus defeat. If we lose, the pharmakon turns poison, and the
game, which previously seemed so promising, so alluring in its evocation of Homeric divine bloodshed, offering laurel crowns for the victor, is now seen as but a miserable reminder of our
own human limitations and faults. Remember my reference to chance, rather than divine intervention, as the cause of the outcome of dice rolls? After the intensity of the game, the losing
player slowly sheds that puerile fantasy of guardian spirits, and takes on the more mature (more miserable!) outlook of the dice rolls being a product of chance. What a terrible discovery!
Mere chance was the barrier to victory? If only the rolls went differently, the game could have been much different. Such thoughts are ample evidence of my claim that the game pharmakon
turns to poison in the event of defeat, and yet there is an interesting point here: mere chance was the barrier to defeat? My reasoning is limited, yes, but it is something that can be
worked on, refined, improved, elevated. Ultimately, within that concentrated ball of poison lies the seed of promise, namely the twofold promise of improved strategy and favourable chance.
It is this seed of promise which makes us return to the game time and time again. We may rage and hoot, as previously described above, at the event of a loss, but we will almost always
return, for the pharmakon never loses its sheen, and poison can be flushed from our system. Indeed, what other choice do we have? Is it better to sit in mere existence, and not attempt the
game? Either way we will be reminded of our mortality, but with the game, the pharmakon, lies the promise of remedy, the promise of victory, which will make all the poisonous defeats
worthwhile.
But is that really the case? Let us examine what happens when the player achieves victory, and the pharmakon of the game renders itself up as remedy to our fleshiness, bestowing a little
glowing piece of Godhood to be enjoyed for the space of an hour or so. On that first form of immortality, namely that achieved through strategy, it is quite obvious to me that the passage
of time puts such confidence to doubt: certainly, I may have won that game well enough, but what will happen in the future? Will my skills wane? What if I face a stronger opponent? There
is nothing more terrible for a man than having to sit down and think about himself for five minutes. Equally, the victor will come to the same realisation of the dice throws that his
defeated opponent comes to, that is, the dice throws were not the product of some theological conflict, but rather the product of mere chance. This is obviously disconcerting, since we
love to vainly bask in the divine light expelled from a six sided die. This undermining of the two immortalities of victory ultimately reveals the converse effect the pharmakon has on the
victor compared to the loser: the defeated man swallows the poison pill, but within his insides springs forth the seed of promise and hope, and he returns to the game again, eager to
acquire his own little piece of immortality. Conversely, the victor drinks deep the lichor of remedy, only to discover that it turns to poison, and serves only to remind him of his own
limitations, his faults, his own mortal nature. Because of this, the victor must return to the game again, as it is not enough to have one piece of God in his possession. He needs a
treasury.
Not enough? But why? Why is man so intent on this? Why does man want to be God, or at least, wants to be like unto God and blessed by Him? I think this leads into an interesting point
that ultimately provides little comfort to me, but at least puts things into perspective. It seems to me that we are all pitiful slaves to death. By this I do not mean that we are merely
subject to his rules, but rather that we possess such great fear of death to the point that it infects all aspects of life. This is why we so eagerly rush to the comforting arms of the
pharmakon, which of course need not be miniature wargames, but pretty much anything else that man occupies himself with in his leisure time: philosphy, history, the arts, sports,
travelling, socialising, whatever else you can list. Within these things lie the converse relationship of victory and defeat: to face defeat in these things entails a return; to face
victory in these things leaves you wanting more. Thus we continue this cycle, time and time again, returning to our favourite pastimes like a drunkard returns to the bottle.
But is that it? As I said before, this discovery leaves little comfort to me, but there is at least a little comfort to be had. I take comfort in that others seem to have not only
recognised these facts, but at least offered up thoughts or even solutions. Kierkegaard and his three stages of man seems to chime in here, since what I am describing may only be
the description of a certain stage of man, namely that of the hedonist (which we may call here the hobbyist). Such a description does not dismiss the possibilities of other means of life,
namely the ethical and spiritual stages which make up the other stages of man in his conception. Another figure that comes to mind is Nietzsche, particularly his notion of the ubermensch.
In this piece I have time and time again emphasised the wargame functioning as a means of achieving temporary Godhood, namely same kind of transcendental state which puts him up and above
the mere material world of frightened and insecure mortals. It is obvious that if this is why people actually play these kinds of games, then the motivation of the player is rooted in this
kind of natural aversion to the mere materiality and finiteness of the world, manifesting itself in that terror of death described by Becker. But surely Nietzche’s ubermensch, a figure so
utterly of THIS world, and no other, would experience nothing of the sort when playing games of this kind. Whether he would play such games is another question, but if he did play such
games, he would not do so out of a desire to escape the mere worldly state of finite human existence, desiring to be some kind of would-be God that transcends the fleshy, creaturely state
of being he occupies through the pharmakon of the game. Another obvious example is the Buddha, who would probably ask why you waste time on some game that only provides temporary (that is, impermanent) access to the divine, a divinity which isn’t actually divine anyway (namely because Buddhism is non-theological, that is, possesses no Godhead, at least nothing like the Abrahamic one). If only becoming Kierkegaard’s knight of faith, or Nietzsche’s ubermensch, or achieving Nirvana was so easy!
While these writings may strike the reader as utterly strange and preoccupied with trivialities, I think that there is something worthwhile in critically thinking through activities such
as strategy games which take up so much of our time and our rational and emotional capacity. We are rightfully concerned about the serious business of life (politics, wars, economy, etc.),
but I believe it is best to leave a little critical thought about the leisurely side of life, and particularly in understanding how the facts of life do not stop at leisure, and in fact
discovering the seemingly innocent activities of recreation may be intertwined with the existential conundrums which we have faced since time immemorial.